I am biased as I have the Roto-Fab, but I went that route to have a true sealed intake that isolates the air charge from the engine compartment completely. When running, the air comes from under the engine compartment and is further isolated by a polymer heatshield. I would hesitate to call it a "ram air" design, but it's probably as close as you can get without cutting a hole somewhere. I will try to post a pic from under the car some time...
The Airaid I'm sure will be a great system, but last I knew they only had the "cold air dam" portion available, which connects to the factory baffled mess that is our stock intake. My other concern is the summertime sun here in the midwest. While the dam may isolate the engine heat, the intake/filter will be sealed directly to the hood and will still be taking the heat from(in my case) a black hood in the blistering heat of a sunny day in Iowa and running it directly into the engine. If you want to know how hot that is come stick your tongue on my hood, but no selfies...

Again, I am admittedly biased, but love the Roto-Fab system, it's looks and it's performance.